User blog comment:ZeroTwo64/User:ZeroTwo64/Madoka is High 2-A ~ "5D Madoka Debunked" Debunked/@comment-30654492-20181129042339

Lemme make this quick. Madoka is only 2-A at best and your logic used to support it is wrong from a scaling standpoint. Of which i will elaborate on momentarily

'Madoka wasn't 3D before ascending to a higher level of existence, but she was 4D. Madoka erased the concept of witch from every timeline and rewrote all the universes (2-A feat) before she defeated the Witch of Despair/The Curse and ascended to a higher plane of existence. Ascending to a higher plane of existence means becoming a higher-dimensional being, and since Madoka was already 4D before she ascended to a higher plane, she became 5D.'

>Effecting an infinite number of universes only makes you 4th Dimensional in power. but this doesn't mean you are a 4th Dimensional Being. Madoka when she did this feat was only 3rd Dimension and her ascending beyond that makes her 4-D. If i were a human who could destroy a Space-Time Continuum, that doesn't mean i am suddenly 4th Dimensional, i'm still a 3rd Dimensional Being who happens to have 4-D Power. According to VBW, Goku can defeat Zamasu, who was one with Space and Time, but does that make him 4th Dimensional. No, he can just only effect dimensions beyond 3

'The Famitsu Magazine doesn't just say that Madoka exists beyond past, present and future, but also beyond the stars. This term is commonly used in astrology to talk about other places of enquiry, that attempt to encompass the entire subject of how we mere mortals handle the occult. The term occult means "knowledge that must be kept hidden", but for most practicing occultists it is simply the study of a deeper spiritual reality that extends pure reason and the physical sciences; it is a reality which is completely unknown to humans, that is.... a higher dimension. "Beyond the stars" is used to talk about a reality which cannot be understand by humans, and if a character was stated to be "Beyond the stars", it is Low 2-C by default; the term is revealed to be a synonym of "beyond space". Madoka was stated to be beyond stars (which means space) and beyond past, present and future (which means time). If a character is beyond both time and space, it is 5D, because five-dimensional space is one more than the usual three spatial dimensions and the fourth dimension of time used in relativitistic physics, meaning it is beyond time and space.'

>That's an Assiocation Fallacy. Madoka being stated to be "Beyond The Stars" is likely another way of saying she's beyond The Universe and not that she is beyond 4th Dimensional Space. Not only is this backed up by The Manga itself (Which states she is beyond The Universe, thus being "beyond the stars"). Existing beyond Space and Time on it's own isn't 5th Dimensional, unless Madoka was stated to be beyond The Multiverse then she'd be 5-D due to Madoka Magica's Multiverse being Infinite